Topic > The Fellowship of the Ring: Text and Film Compared

Tolkien's colorful world of Middle-earth has been a place of escapist adventure in the minds of many since its humble beginnings in the mid-1950s. Since the debut of his novel The Fellowship of the Ring, he has inspired minds with his epic tales of unprecedented courage, touched hearts with his scenes of sacrificial love, and honored people's souls with his most profound philosophical comments on who we are as a society and as individuals. Peter Jackson willingly accepted the responsibility of moving these elements into a new medium in 1997, when he obtained the rights to begin producing a film adaptation. Although under pressure to accurately recreate the world of The Lord of the Rings, Jackson excelled, creating a film that reflects the book almost perfectly and is a classic in its own right. Effective casting, award-winning soundtracks and captivating filmmaking techniques are all used to enhance Jackson's detailed and accurate retelling of a timeless story. Readers of the novel connect emotionally with Tolkien's characters and creating coherence in the film required the casting of appropriate and effective actors. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on "Why Violent Video Games Shouldn't Be Banned"? Get an Original Essay Characterization is always an important aspect in any adaptation from one media format to another. How characters are portrayed to meet readers' prior expectations is a critical element to any successful adaptation. The actors were chosen in The Fellowship of the Ring to reflect the appearances, mannerisms and personalities of the original characters. Jackson went to great lengths to cast actors who actually played their characters, and a clear example of this dedication is found in the casting of the character Aragorn. In The Fellowship of the Ring, Aragorn is a confident, competent, and strong character. His rough appearance is somewhat deceptive, as he is actually an heir to the throne, and this royalty becomes increasingly apparent over the course of the novel. After Stuart Townsend's offer to play the role was rejected, Viggo Mortensen was cast; due to his commanding presence, his older appearance, and his ability to demonstrate Aragorn's worried yet confident personality. The main character of the film and the film is Frodo Baggins, an inexperienced, knowledgeable and somewhat introverted hobbit who is given the task of destroying the Ring. In choosing this character, a young adult was needed who could represent the immense emotion experienced by Frodo in the novel, while at the same time playing the role of a happy and carefree young man found in the opening chapters. Elijah Wood has been extremely successful in developing the dynamic characterization found in the literary character and his extensive acting experience; in both comedy and philosophical drama, it made him appropriate for the role. Due to the novel's fantasy nature, makeup artists and visual effects were used to match appearances with characters that reside in readers' imaginations. These attempts to create characters that reflected Tolkien's comprehensive descriptions were award-winning, with the film receiving Academy Awards for "Best Makeup" and "Best Visual Effects". The cast of The Fellowship of the Ring successfully reflects the characters in readers' imaginations, seamlessly bringing them to the big screen. However, other elements of a novel must also be considered when transferring a story from one medium to another. Iconic scenes are one of these elements and, as they remain imprinted in the memoryof readers, you need to be very careful about telling them successfully in another medium. . Tolkien's novel is full of iconic scenes, masterful strokes of detailed storytelling, providing the reader with vivid images of the setting, characters, and actions taking place. Due to timeHowever, due to the constraints placed on films, many scenes have to be shortened or omitted. The simple omission often leaves readers dissatisfied, and not all scenes can be shortened. For these reasons, Jackson combined several scenes, maintaining the meaning and significance of the original scenes while reducing the time taken to depict them. One such scene occurs when the Fellowship is introduced to the Ringwraiths. Various cinematic techniques are used to bring tension and an inherent sense of horror to the scene. As they walk along a path in the woods, the sound of horses' hooves is heard and they quickly dive off the path, aware that they are being chased. They take refuge under the root of a large tree and all ambient noise from the birds ceases. The camera pans down, looking through the undergrowth towards the hidden hobbits and the Ringwraith above. This low angle gives a sense of vulnerability and immediately vilifies the Ringwraith, showing his immense power and evil intentions. The sharp and angular iron armor he wears provides strong connotations of cruelty and strength. The next camera angle places the Wraith's hand directly above the hobbits, revealing how close he actually is. Insects and worms then come out of the ground around the hobbits, showing the repugnance of the Wraith, which even nature is repelled by. At this point, quiet, haunting music plays, deepening the tension and providing an element of suspense. The Ghost's evil presence begins to overwhelm Frodo, and he goes to put the Ring on his finger. The volume of the soundtrack increases, signaling the importance of this action, and close-ups of the characters convey their emotional reaction. The Wraith is then distracted and leaves with a horrifying scream. Foley used various animal-like noises for the scream to create a terrifying sound effect that reflects the book. Tolkien writes: "darkness attended them and they cried out with voices of death", and this is accurately depicted in the film. This timeless scene is the result of the combination of two crucial experiences in the book. In one, Frodo "threw himself into a patch of long grass behind a tree", with the other hobbits hiding in a depression on the side of the road. The second scene of the book describes how the Hobbits "had no time to find a better hiding place than the general darkness under the trees". In this scene, they were hiding behind a tree trunk and Frodo crept cautiously towards the road to observe his enemy. The artful blend of these two scenes preserves the scenery and the characters' actions as they hide behind a tree from an unknown enemy. It also conveys the intense fear and horror of the Ringwraith that is present in the novel. This scene from the film uses multiple semiotic codes to successfully meet the reader's expectations and convey the concepts present in the book. When used successfully, semiotic codes provide deeper meaning and understanding to a film's viewers, better recreating aspects of a novel in a film. Howard Shore's musical composition for The Fellowship of the Ring is extremely clever in the way he uses the musical device of leitmotifs throughout the film. This technique involves assigning a musical score to a particular group of people, or place, and creating variations of that score,.