Topic > Neel Burton on Suicide: A Personal Reflection

Neel Burton wrote an article in 2012 questioning whether suicide is right or wrong. He listed arguments from many different points of view and from different people and places. One theory is that saving someone's life and committing suicide goes against God's will. The theory about saving someone's life was a counterargument against the Roman Catholic Church's belief that the life you live belongs to God, therefore committing suicide would mean taking a life that technically doesn't belong to you. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on "Why Violent Video Games Shouldn't Be Banned"? Get an original essay David Hume was the philosopher who made this argument against the Roman Catholic Church. He believed that committing suicide was wrong in the eyes of God, so saving someone's life was wrong. David Hume also suffered from depression and had written two essays for a book that had to be removed due to controversy over the topics. He promoted the idea of ​​fear of dying and fear of disappointing God as the reason why people commit suicide, to clear their conscience. However, there are some cultures that promote suicide as a good thing. Tibetan monks kill themselves, but they call it personal sacrifice. They consider it honorable because it is usually done by these monks to protest something they believed was wrong. This goes hand in hand with the argument of the natural philosopher Pliny the Elder. His statement was about the fact that humans have the ability to commit suicide and puts them at an advantage over God. Another dispute about suicide is whether it is considered illegal. On the other hand, some people believe that if people voluntarily commit suicide, it is good for society. In 2014, the Indian government wanted to decriminalize suicide, so it removed a section of its laws that made it illegal (MD ). The problem is that people with mental health problems and disabilities cannot make rational decisions. , Therefore this particular issue would be extremely difficult to regulate. Some existentialist philosophers play devil's advocate and say that you need to demonstrate the meaning of your life in order not to commit suicide. Nihilistic philosophers argue that suicide has no meaning, nothing has meaning. The article pushed the idea that if you are pro-life you believe the person has no right to commit suicide no matter what. Another argument is that suicide is almost always an act of sadness. It is usually never a rational decision that is planned. The most common argument is that suicide is selfish and hurts all the people left behind. The final topic is about good or evil and depends on our story. In other words, the article states that throughout our lives we have things and do things that make us happy, but death takes them away from us. The purpose of this argumentative article is to convince you to believe whether suicide is right or wrong. It also informs you of all the different opinions on this topic. This article is written by a man named Neel Burton MD. He is a psychiatrist, philosopher, writer and teacher (Psychology Today). Knowing these things he draws the conclusion that he wrote this for people thinking of committing suicide and for people who deal with people who want to commit suicide. The genre is nonfiction because the article contains facts and research. Many philosophers have contributed their opinions to this article, making it appealing to a wide audience. His position is not clear in the article. He touched base on almost every topic of suicide and more. The author mainly uses logos in his argument. It's very direct, in the.